Imagine you get the chance to play piccolo, but you don’t have one yet. So you look at cheaper piccolos but start to wonder about Mendini piccolo alternatives.
While a cheap piccolo sounds great, you will make sacrifices. Read on to learn if Mendini is worth it or if you should consider the competition.
But first, this post contains affiliate links. Read the full disclosure policy to learn more.
What Is the Mendini Piccolo?
The Mendini piccolo (or piccolos) are on the lower end of the scale when it comes to piccolo prices. You can choose between an all-metal model and one with a metal headjoint and a plastic body.
Both options are significantly less expensive than comparable models from more established brands. That can make them a good option for absolute beginners.
While some players and teachers will tell you not to waste your time, I believe these instruments have a place. If you have no other options but want to try the piccolo, a cheaper model can help you get started.
Benefits of a Mendini Piccolo
Before you avoid this brand completely, consider a few ways in which it may outshine the competition. Then, you can determine if you should give this low-cost piccolo a try.
More Affordable
Probably the most obvious benefit is that Mendini piccolos are cheaper than their alternatives. Whether you don’t have much money, can’t rent a piccolo, or have some other obstacle, this brand lets you try the instrument.
You may not be able to make this piccolo your main instrument for years, but that’s okay. It works well enough to let you test the smaller flute and see if it’s the right choice for you.
As you get the hang of playing the piccolo, you can search for a more advanced model. You’ll also have a bit of time to save up for something that will help you get even better at the piccolo.
Two Models
Another thing I appreciate about the Mendini piccolo is that there’s more than one model. Most other low-cost brands only make a metal instrument, probably because that’s a pretty cheap way to go.
Mendini certainly sells a metal piccolo. However, they also sell one that features a plastic body, which can help you get a warmer sound that’s easier to blend with other instruments.
You can compare the pros and cons of metal and plastic piccolos to decide which better meets your needs. Then, you can get a nice starter model.
Good for Beginners
For better or worse, you won’t see professionals playing on Mendini piccolos. However, they’re still a suitable choice for absolute beginner players.
If you find you can’t afford other student model piccolos but still want to give the instrument a go, consider Mendini. You may need to upgrade sooner rather than later.
But a piccolo is better than none if you think you might like playing the instrument. You can spend a few weeks or months playing the Mendini before moving on to a more expensive piccolo.
Benefits of Mendini Piccolo Alternatives
Before you rush to purchase a piccolo from the brand, consider a few advantages of Mendini piccolo alternatives. Other brands may have the features you need to make the most of your studies.
Better Quality
Yes, Mendini piccolos are super cheap, and there’s a place for that. However, more expensive brands are usually made of better quality.
That means the piccolos will be able to handle more use, especially student models made of plastic. You’ll get more playing out of your piccolo before you have to splurge for an upgrade.
And when you have a nice quality instrument, you’ll have an easier time learning and practicing. That can keep you interested in learning the piccolo and getting better at it.
More Model Options
Mendini piccolo alternatives span multiple brands. That means you’ll have way more options when it comes to your piccolo if you consider more than one brand.
While Mendini makes metal and plastic instruments, there are also composite piccolos as well as wood piccolos. Granted, wood isn’t suitable for beginners, but it’s still out there.
If you stick to one brand (Mendini or otherwise), you can really limit yourself. You might miss out on a piccolo that works perfectly with you and your body.
Easier Response
Combine the previous two reasons to get a better response on your new piccolo. Good quality instruments tend to work better, so it’s often worth spending more money.
Not only that, but testing different materials and features allows you to find a piccolo that works well for you. That way, you can enjoy practicing and learning.
You won’t have to fight your instrument to get a good sound. And you won’t risk having that struggle be the thing that makes you quit playing.
Mendini Piccolo Alternatives
So you’re interested in more piccolo brands, but you don’t know what Mendini piccolo alternatives to consider. Here are some of the best brands and models for students.
Yamaha YPC-32
The Yamaha YPC-32 is most similar to the metal and plastic Mendini. However, Yamaha piccolos are much more popular, especially among students.
While I’ve never played this specific model, I know multiple people who have. They all sound great on this piccolo, and it’s a super durable model as well.
You should give this one a try, particularly if you have and love a Yamaha flute. You’ll get the same quality and response you expect from Yamaha instruments.
Jupiter JPC1000
Another option worth trying is the Jupiter JPC1000. It’s about the same price as the Yamaha, and it has all of the same specs, from the metal headjoint to the plastic body.
Like the Yamaha, I also haven’t played this model myself. However, Jupiter is a well-known and trustworthy brand, so it’s a good option to consider for students.
You can get a good response and a nice tone from the instrument. Then, you’ll enjoy playing and learning the basics of the smaller flute.
Pearl 105
If you want a composite piccolo instead, consider the Pearl 105. It’s both an alternative to the Mendini as well as a nice upgrade if you start on the cheaper brand.
You’ll get a split E mechanism, which helps you play high E with less resistance. Meanwhile, the composite material gives you the warm tone of wood without the risk of cracks.
This piccolo is also relatively affordable for what you get. I played on this piccolo after college and through grad school, and it’s still my backup piccolo.
Armstrong 307
The Armstrong 307 is another piccolo with a metal headjoint and a plastic body. While I haven’t played this model, I did play the similar 204, which is all-metal.
Armstrong flutes are great for students who need something durable, like for marching band. I loved my Armstrong, and I still have it for whenever I may need it.
If you can find an older one, you’ll be in for a treat. Just make sure to get it serviced before you try to play it so that it’s in working condition.
Is Mendini a Good Piccolo Brand?
Mendini isn’t the worst piccolo brand, but it’s also not as popular as some others. It can be a suitable choice for beginners on a budget who don’t have access to another instrument.
However, I wouldn’t recommend it to advancing or professional players.
Final Thoughts
Before you buy your next piccolo, look into some Mendini piccolo alternatives. These brands are more expensive, but they have a lot of good features that make them worth the cost.
That way, you’ll look forward to playing the piccolo! And if you’re ready to get started, check out our resources page for more information.